Thriller novels are a popular genre thanks to their gripping stories, suspenseful plotlines, and compelling characters. Two such novels – Michael Connelly’s “The Concrete Blonde” and Lars Emmerich’s “The Blowback Protocol” – are both beloved by fans of the genre. In this article, we will delve deep into both novels to compare and contrast their writing styles, characters, themes, and settings to analyze which one of these two novels emerges as the better of the two. So, settle into your seat, turn down the lights, and let’s begin our journey into the world of these thrilling novels.
Introduction: Brief Overview of the Two Novels
Before diving deep into the comparison, let us first provide a brief overview of both novels. “The Concrete Blonde” is the third novel in Michael Connelly’s Harry Bosch Series, published in 1994. The novel revolves around the character of Detective Harry Bosch who is on trial for killing a suspect nicknamed the “The Dollmaker,” who was responsible for the murder of twelve women. The novel details the investigation that follows Harry’s indictment and the scandalous revelations that come to light during the trial.
Lars Emmerich’s “The Blowback Protocol,” on the other hand, was published in 2013 and portrays the experiences of the novel’s protagonist, Alex Devereaux, a former CIA agent on the run from the agency after she stumbles upon a shadowy conspiracy. She teams up with a former KGB agent to unearth the conspiracy but soon realizes that they’re being chased by assassins while they’re in Europe.
Despite the differences in plot and characters, both novels share a common theme of corruption and the struggle for justice. While “The Concrete Blonde” focuses on the corruption within the justice system, “The Blowback Protocol” highlights the corruption within the intelligence agencies. Both novels also feature strong, determined protagonists who are willing to risk everything to uncover the truth and bring the corrupt individuals to justice.
Plot Summary of The Concrete Blonde
The Concrete Blonde is based on the investigation surrounding the murder of twelve women. In the novel, Harry is on trial for killing a suspect who he believes to be the killer. Harry hires Mickey Haller as his defense attorney, who helps Harry in his defense. Things soon take a turn when new evidence comes to light, exposing Harry’s mistake, and the investigation reaches new heights of intensity.
As the investigation progresses, Harry and his team discover that the real killer is still out there, and they must race against time to catch him before he strikes again. The case becomes even more complicated when they realize that the killer has been following Harry, and may be targeting him as his next victim. With the help of his colleagues and Mickey Haller, Harry must navigate through the twists and turns of the case to bring the killer to justice and clear his own name.
Character Analysis of Harry Bosch in The Concrete Blonde
Harry Bosch is a complex character who takes a prominent part in the novel. He appears as a strong-willed and determined detective who understands the truth and is willing to fight for it. But he also has a dark side to him, being highly competitive and emotionally distant from his friends and family. He is also haunted by his past experiences that have left deep psychological scars and often leads him on a path of self-destruction.
Despite his flaws, Harry Bosch is a highly skilled detective who is respected by his colleagues and feared by his enemies. He has a sharp mind and an eye for detail, which allows him to solve even the most complex cases. He is also a man of principles, who is not afraid to stand up for what he believes in, even if it means going against his superiors or risking his own life.
Throughout the novel, Harry Bosch’s character undergoes a transformation as he confronts his past and comes to terms with his inner demons. He learns to open up to his friends and family, and to trust others, which helps him to become a better detective and a better person. By the end of the novel, Harry Bosch emerges as a more well-rounded and empathetic character, who is ready to face whatever challenges lie ahead.
Plot Summary of The Blowback Protocol
The Blowback Protocol is the story of Alex Devereaux, a former CIA agent on a mission to find out the truth about her mentor’s death. She teams up with her mentor’s former KGB agent to unearth a conspiracy but soon finds herself in the crosshairs of the conspiracy’s assassins, all while she is in Europe. Her journey leads her to a revelation about her own past and a dark shadow that has been following her since her days as a CIA agent.
As Alex delves deeper into the conspiracy, she discovers that her mentor’s death was not an isolated incident, but part of a larger plot to destabilize the world order. She uncovers a network of corrupt politicians, businessmen, and intelligence agents who are willing to do whatever it takes to maintain their power and control.
With the help of her KGB ally, Alex fights to expose the truth and bring the conspirators to justice. But as she gets closer to the heart of the conspiracy, she realizes that her own life is in danger and that she may not be able to trust anyone, not even her closest allies.
Character Analysis of Alex Devereaux in The Blowback Protocol
Alex Devereaux is a highly skilled and determined former CIA agent who is on a quest to uncover the truth about a dark conspiracy. Her bravery and daring are undoubtedly her biggest strengths, but at the same time, her past has left her with emotional scars and a lot of trust issues. Her character is complex and intriguing, filled with layers of secrets that gradually unfold over the course of the novel.
Writing Style Comparison between Connelly and Emmerich
The writing styles of Connelly and Emmerich are quite different. Connelly’s style is more traditional, grounded, and laden with details, while Emmerich’s style is more fast-paced, with a focus on action over description. However, both authors excel in their respective styles, creating suspenseful storylines and engaging characters that keep the reader on the edge of their seat.
Themes and Motifs in The Concrete Blonde
The Concrete Blonde deals with several themes, including the nature of justice, the consequences of wrongful accusations, and the costs of ambition. The motif of justice runs throughout the novel, with Harry always seeking to bring the real killer to justice, even at the cost of his own career.
Themes and Motifs in The Blowback Protocol
The Blowback Protocol explores themes surrounding power, corruption, and distrust of authority. The novel portrays various institutions and individuals who are willing to go to great lengths to cover up their nefarious deeds. The motif of betrayal also plays a large role, with many of the novel’s characters revealing hidden motives in the course of the story.
Setting Comparison: Los Angeles versus Europe
In The Concrete Blonde, the setting of Los Angeles plays a significant role by ranging from the gritty alleys of Hollywood to the plush estates of Beverly Hills. Meanwhile, The Blowback Protocol takes place in various European cities from Paris to Brussels to Berlin, and the cities’ cultural and historical significance is brought into play to create a unique atmosphere.
Critical Reception and Awards for Both Novels
The Concrete Blonde was a critical and commercial success, receiving many positive reviews and the Mystery Writers of America Edgar Award for Best Novel in 1995. The Blowback Protocol was also well-received by critics, with particular praise for its fast-paced plot and the depth of its characters.
Conclusion: Which Novel is Better?
Comparing both novels, it is clear that both authors have created thrilling, engaging stories with fascinating characters and unique settings. One cannot say which of the novels is better as both cater to a different audience. The Concrete Blonde caters to the more traditional readers of the mystery/thriller genre, while The Blowback Protocol caters to readers who prefer a more fast-paced, action-oriented novel. Ultimately, the choice between the two novels will depend on the reader’s personal preferences.