Thriller novels have always been a favorite among readers for their fast-paced action, suspenseful plot, and intriguing characters. Among the most popular thriller authors today are Nelson DeMille and Lars Emmerich, both known for their gripping and thought-provoking novels. In this article, we compare and contrast DeMille’s “Plum Island” and Emmerich’s “Devolution” on various aspects such as plot, characters, setting, themes explored, writing style, and reception.
An Overview of Nelson DeMille’s “Plum Island”
Nelson DeMille’s “Plum Island” is a mystery thriller novel that tells the story of John Corey, a retired NYPD homicide detective who now works as a special investigator for the FBI. The novel is set in Long Island, New York, and revolves around the investigation of the murder of two scientists at Plum Island Animal Disease Center. Corey soon discovers that the murders are linked to a secret research project related to biological warfare.
The novel is known for its vivid descriptions of the Long Island landscape and its portrayal of the scientific research community. DeMille’s attention to detail and his ability to create complex, multi-dimensional characters make “Plum Island” a gripping read that keeps readers on the edge of their seats until the very end. The novel has been praised for its realistic portrayal of the FBI and its investigative techniques, as well as its exploration of the ethical dilemmas surrounding biological warfare research.
An Overview of Lars Emmerich’s “Devolution”
Lars Emmerich’s “Devolution” is a post-apocalyptic thriller novel set in the Pacific Northwest. The novel tells the story of Angie West, a young woman who survives a pandemic that wipes out most of humanity. She soon discovers that the pandemic was caused by a government experiment gone wrong, and that she is immune to the virus. With only a few survivors left, Angie sets out on a dangerous journey to find the truth and save humanity.
Throughout the novel, Emmerich explores themes of survival, government corruption, and the consequences of playing with nature. Angie’s journey is not only physical, but also emotional as she grapples with the loss of her loved ones and the weight of responsibility on her shoulders. Emmerich’s vivid descriptions of the post-apocalyptic world and the characters’ struggles make “Devolution” a gripping and thought-provoking read.
Plot Analysis: Similarities between “Plum Island” and “Devolution”
Despite having different settings and themes, “Plum Island” and “Devolution” share some significant similarities in their plot. Both novels involve government conspiracies related to biological warfare, where secret research projects go wrong and cause devastating consequences. Both novels also feature protagonists who are investigating the conspiracy and trying to uncover the truth. However, “Plum Island” focuses more on the investigation of the murder, whereas “Devolution” is about survival in a post-apocalyptic world.
Another similarity between the two novels is the use of suspense and tension to keep the readers engaged. Both authors use cliffhangers and unexpected plot twists to create a sense of anticipation and keep the readers guessing. Additionally, both novels explore the theme of the dangers of unchecked scientific experimentation and the potential consequences of playing with nature.
Despite the similarities, there are also some notable differences between the two novels. For example, “Plum Island” is set in a more realistic world, whereas “Devolution” is set in a world where humans have devolved into primitive creatures. Furthermore, “Plum Island” is more of a traditional mystery novel, whereas “Devolution” is a blend of horror and survival genres. Nevertheless, both novels are captivating and thought-provoking, and they offer a unique perspective on the consequences of human actions.
Character Analysis: The Protagonists of “Plum Island” and “Devolution”
The protagonists of both novels are quite different in terms of their background, personality, and motivation. John Corey in “Plum Island” is a retired NYPD detective who has a dry sense of humor and a cynical attitude towards authority figures. He is motivated by his sense of duty and justice and is willing to risk his life to uncover the truth. On the other hand, Angie West in “Devolution” is a young woman with a traumatic past who is struggling to survive in a harsh and dangerous world. She is motivated by her love for her sister and her desire to save humanity from extinction.
Despite their differences, both protagonists share a common trait: they are both highly skilled and resourceful. John Corey’s experience as a detective gives him a keen eye for detail and the ability to think on his feet, while Angie West’s survival skills and knowledge of the wilderness make her a formidable opponent to any threat. Both characters are able to adapt to their surroundings and use their strengths to overcome obstacles.
Another notable difference between the two protagonists is their approach to relationships. John Corey is a bit of a lone wolf, preferring to work alone and not relying on anyone else. Angie West, on the other hand, values the relationships she has with others and is willing to work with a team to achieve her goals. This difference in approach adds an interesting dynamic to the stories and highlights the importance of human connection in times of crisis.
Setting Comparison: Long Island vs the Pacific Northwest
The settings of “Plum Island” and “Devolution” are vastly different, both geographically and culturally. “Plum Island” is set in Long Island, New York, which is known for its beaches, wineries, and affluent communities. The novel portrays Long Island as a beautiful and peaceful place with a dark underbelly of government secrecy. In contrast, “Devolution” is set in the Pacific Northwest, which is a region of rugged mountains, dense forests, and wildlife. The novel portrays the Pacific Northwest as a dangerous and isolated place after the apocalypse, where survival is the only goal.
Long Island is a densely populated area with a rich history and culture. It is home to many famous landmarks, such as the Montauk Lighthouse and the Hamptons. The novel “Plum Island” captures the essence of Long Island’s beauty and charm, while also highlighting the darker aspects of the island’s history.
The Pacific Northwest, on the other hand, is known for its natural beauty and outdoor recreation opportunities. It is home to many national parks, including Mount Rainier and Olympic National Park. The novel “Devolution” portrays the Pacific Northwest as a place of extreme danger and isolation, where the natural world has taken over and humans are struggling to survive.
Themes Explored in Both Novels: Government Conspiracy, Biological Warfare, and Environmentalism
Both “Plum Island” and “Devolution” explore similar themes related to government conspiracy, biological warfare, and environmentalism. The novels raise questions about the morality of scientific experiments, the role of government in protecting its citizens, and the impact of human activity on the environment. However, “Plum Island” focuses more on the conspiracy and cover-up, while “Devolution” explores the aftermath of a catastrophic event and its impact on the survivors.
Writing Style Comparison: DeMille vs Emmerich
The writing styles of DeMille and Emmerich are quite distinct, reflecting their different backgrounds and experiences. DeMille’s style is often humorous and satirical, with a focus on dialogue and character development. His novels are known for their intricate plots and attention to detail. Emmerich’s style, on the other hand, is more straightforward and action-oriented, with a focus on fast-paced scenes and suspenseful moments. His novels often explore complex themes with a sense of urgency.
Reception and Criticism of Both Novels
“Plum Island” and “Devolution” have both received mostly positive reviews from critics and readers alike. “Plum Island” is praised for its intricate plot, engaging characters, and witty dialogue. Some criticisms of the novel include its slow pacing and predictable ending. “Devolution” is praised for its action-packed scenes, thought-provoking themes, and strong female protagonist. Some criticisms of the novel include its lack of character development and plot holes.
Which Novel is Better? A Comparative Review of “Plum Island” and “Devolution”
Both “Plum Island” and “Devolution” are excellent examples of the thriller genre, each with its strengths and weaknesses. “Plum Island” is a more traditional mystery thriller with a focus on character development and humor. “Devolution” is a more action-packed post-apocalyptic thriller with a focus on survival and environmentalism. It ultimately depends on personal preferences, but both novels are highly recommended for anyone looking for a gripping and thought-provoking read.
In conclusion, Nelson DeMille’s “Plum Island” and Lars Emmerich’s “Devolution” are two excellent examples of the thriller genre, each with unique strengths and weaknesses. Despite having different settings, themes, and writing styles, the novels share some significant similarities in terms of the plot and themes explored. Both novels are highly recommended for anyone looking for a thrilling and thought-provoking read.